Beyond the SMAS Lift: Why Releasing Retaining Ligaments is the Key to a 10-Year Result

Table of Contents

Imagine investing over $10,000 in a facelift, only to see your face sagging back to its original state just five years later. It’s a disheartening experience that no patient should have to go through.

On the surface, every procedure is called a “Facelift,” but the actual surgical technique varies drastically from one clinic to another. Some surgeons only address the shallow layers of the skin, while others go deep to separate the retaining ligaments.

A difference of just 3mm in the depth of dissection can result in a gap of several years in your results. This tiny margin is exactly what creates the divide between a 5-year result and a 10-year one.


The 5-Year Facelift: What’s Missing?

Why do some results begin to fade after only five years?

The primary culprit is insufficient dissection. While many clinics claim to work on the SMAS (muscle layer), they often stop their work once they reach the mid-cheek area.

This is because the area around the nasolabial folds (smile lines) is densely packed with complex nerves and blood vessels, making it a high-risk zone that many surgeons hesitate to navigate. However, this is precisely where the quality of the result is determined.

If the area near the smile lines isn’t sufficiently loosened, the retaining ligaments—the “cords” that anchor your facial tissue to the bone—remain intact. If you pull the surface skin without releasing these anchors, what happens?

It’s like grabbing the middle of a rubber band and pulling only one end.

The side you pull might stretch, but the part being held stays exactly where it is. No matter how much tension you apply, the areas anchored by those ligaments will never truly lift.

In my 19 years of consulting for revision surgeries, the most heartbreaking cases are those who say: “It looked great for six months, but by the one-year mark, my smile lines were back.” Upon examination, the sagging always reappears exactly where those retaining ligaments were left untouched.

Moving only the surface tissue while leaving the deep structure unchanged is a temporary fix. The secret to longevity lies in the depths you cannot see.


The 10-Year Result: Defined by 1mm of Precision

What makes a facelift last for over a decade? Here is the difference in my approach:

1. Complete Release of Retaining Ligaments

We meticulously identify the nerves and vessels around the smile lines and navigate between them to disconnect the ligaments one by one. This is like dismantling the load-bearing pillars of a building; it structurally removes the downward pull that gravity has on your face.

2. The Dual-Plane Approach

While a standard “Deep Plane” lift often moves the muscle and skin as one unit, I prefer the Dual-Plane method.

  • The Muscle (SMAS): Tightened firmly to provide a strong foundation.
  • The Skin: Repositioned naturally to avoid a “pulled” look.
  • Multi-Directional Fixing: Think of it like pitching a tent. If you pull only one rope, it’s unstable. If you secure it with multiple ropes from different angles, it withstands the wind. Your face stays lifted longer when anchored in multiple directions against gravity.

3. The “Golden Angle” of Suspension

Even with deep dissection, the angle at which we secure the tissue changes everything. Pulling too vertically can look unnatural, while pulling too horizontally yields weak results. Finding the exact degree tailored to a patient’s bone structure, skin condition, and fat distribution is the final touch of a master surgeon.


Conclusion: Choose the Technique, Not the Name

In the end, small details determine time. A 1mm difference in depth and a few degrees in direction create the gap between 5 and 10 years of youthfulness. When choosing a surgeon, don’t just look at the name of the procedure—look at the precision of the method.


FAQ

Q1. Why do some facelifts only last 5 years while others last 10?

A: The difference lies in the depth of the dissection. A “5-year facelift” often only addresses the surface or stops the muscle (SMAS) work at the mid-cheek. A “10-year facelift” involves a much deeper and more precise dissection, reaching the smile lines and fully releasing the structural anchors of the face.

Q2. What are “retaining ligaments,” and why are they so important?

A: Think of retaining ligaments as tough elastic cords that tether your facial tissue to the bone. If a surgeon simply pulls the skin without releasing these cords, the ligaments will act like an anchor, pulling the face back down to its original saggy position. Releasing these is the secret to a natural and long-lasting lift.

Q3. I’ve heard of “Deep Plane” facelifts. How is your “Dual-Plane” method different?

A: While a standard Deep Plane lift moves the muscle and skin layers together, the Dual-Plane method treats them independently. We tighten the SMAS (muscle) layer firmly for a strong foundation and reposition the skin layer naturally in a different direction. This “multi-directional” anchoring is much more effective at resisting gravity over time.

Q4. Will a deeper dissection make my face look “over-pulled” or unnatural?

A: Actually, the opposite is true. Unnatural looks often come from pulling the skin too tight without addressing the deep structures. By releasing the ligaments and lifting the deep layers, we can achieve a significant lift with zero tension on the skin, resulting in a refreshed, youthful, and completely natural appearance.

Q5. How does the “angle” of the lift affect how long the results last?

A: The angle is everything. If the lift is too vertical, it can look “surprised”; if it’s too horizontal, the effect is weak. We calculate the “Golden Angle” based on your specific bone structure and fat distribution. Finding this precise degree ensures the tissue is supported optimally, preventing it from sagging again prematurely.

Picture of Dr.Shin
Dr.Shin

Hello. I am Dr. Dong-woo Shin, Chief Surgeon at Planet Plastic Surgery.

As a board-certified plastic surgeon, I started this blog to provide accurate and reliable information directly to those who are considering cosmetic procedures or surgeries, particularly facelifts.
 
My sincere hope is that you are able to gather the right information and make fully informed decisions before moving forward with any treatment or surgery.